Hungarian Education II: Four Nobel Truths
Read the original on Slate Star Codex →
Follows up on
↳ The Atomic Bomb Considered As Hungarian High School Science Fair Project — Essay · May 2017
Summary
Part II of the Hungarian Education series — a short data rebuttal to a commenter's objection that Israel, with even more Ashkenazi Jews than Hungary, has unimpressive Nobel numbers (so the Ashkenazi-genius theory fails). Scott counters: (1) total-Nobels-ever / modern-population unfairly favors older countries (Israel founded 1948, busy with kibbutzim and wars); (2) restricting to Nobels since 2000, Israel has the highest per capita; (3) isolating Ashkenazim, Israeli Ashkenazim get ~5x more than any country; (4) but US Ashkenazim get ~2x Israeli Ashkenazim and many Israeli laureates worked abroad, so there's no clear benefit-to-concentration and the education system may matter. Careful (he avoids optional stopping, defers to Wikipedia) but small-sample (eight laureates).
Why this score
Quality 58 · Solid. Solid, high (58). A competent, careful statistical response to an objection, but short, chart-dependent, mid-series, and resting on small samples and a contested hypothesis.
Claude’s paradigm shift 42 · Moderate. Moderate, low (42). A data rebuttal within an ongoing series; modest novelty.
Real-world impact 2 · Minor. Minor (2). A niche contribution to the Ashkenazi-achievement discourse; no material effect.