Scott Alexander, curated
← Back to curation

Abraham Lincoln, Ape-Man

Quality
55
Solid
Claude Shift
14
None
RWI
0
of 10
Humor level 3 badge: Scissor StatementHumorScissor Statementsplits the room

Summary

One of Scott's first SSC posts (the LiveJournal→SSC launch, Feb 2013). A comedic deep-dive into Dr. Fayette Hall's crackpot 19th-century book 'The Copperhead,' which claims Lincoln was a phrenological ape-man who gained the presidency via a voodoo prophecy and séances and then took dictatorial orders from the ghost of Attila the Hun. Scott quotes the absurd phrenology, the 'checkmate liberals' ape illustration, the Mary Todd voodoo courtship, and the séance, deadpanning throughout ('luckily we as a nation have moved beyond these superficial comparisons'). Played for laughs; 'to be continued.'

Why this score

Quality 55 · Solid. Solid (comedy). Genuinely funny — the crackpot source material is gold and Scott's deadpan framing lands — but slight and early (a 1,422-word curiosity-share launching the blog, never substantively continued). Scored in the comedy-piece cluster (Search-Terms/Pope-and-Change 53–54), a touch above for the quality of the material.

Claude’s paradigm shift 14 · None. None (14). Comedic commentary on an old crackpot book; no novelty.

Real-world impact 0 · Negligible. Negligible (0). Pure comedy; no reach.

Humor 3/5 · Scissor Statement. 3 — Scissor. Gate passes: the piece's purpose is comedic entertainment (mocking a crackpot book), intentional throughout. Magnitude 3 (primarily comedic, real laughs from the absurd source + deadpan); not 4 (no helpless-laughter quality).