Scott Alexander, curated
← Back to curation

How Often Do Men Think About Rome?

Quality
58
Solid
Claude Shift
25
Slight
RWI
1
of 10
Humor level 1 badge: Lizardman’s ConstantHumorLizardman’s Constantstatistical noise

Summary

Uses the ACX survey to test the 'men constantly think about the Roman Empire' meme. Result: 38% of women vs 43% of men had thought about Rome in the past 24 hours -- roughly equal, a mild win for the feminist objection. Demographic notes: religious people, the far-right (73% of self-rated 10/10 conservatives!), and lawyers think about Rome more; more-educated people slightly less. The bulk of the post is a long, deliberately-curated catalogue of respondents' Rome contexts (Marcus Aurelius highlights, Byzantine military doctrine, 'how many 4-year-olds I could take in a fight', the ghost of Heliogabalus), most sourced from blogs/podcasts (ACOUP), religion, and memes. Closes: a victory for feminism, but the real winner is Rome.

Why this score

Quality 58 · Solid. Solid. A light, charming meme-debunk -- the equal-rates finding is mildly interesting, but it's a frivolous survey piece whose main draw is the amusing response catalogue. Slight in substance.

Claude’s paradigm shift 25 · Slight. Slight. A survey result on an internet meme; no novel idea.

Real-world impact 1 · Negligible. Negligible. A fun survey post; no real-world reach. 0-1 band.

Humor 1/5 · Lizardman’s Constant. Borderline 1. Humor is a KEY COMPONENT (docx criterion) -- the curated funny-response catalogue is half the post and is featured for laughs, so the gate passes -- but only at the minimum level: the comedy is reader-sourced curation, not Scott's authored comic writing, and the spine is an empirical survey result. (Flagged as a deliberate borderline call vs 0.)